Remote Access and File Transfer

Protocol Overviews

Telnet (Telecommunication Network)

  • Purpose: Provides unencrypted command-line access to remote devices.

  • Port: TCP/23.

  • Security: No encryption; credentials and data transmitted in plaintext.

  • Use Cases: Legacy systems, internal networks (discouraged in modern environments).

SSH (Secure Shell)

  • Purpose: Encrypted replacement for Telnet, enabling secure remote access and command execution.

  • Port: TCP/22.

  • Security: Strong encryption (AES, ChaCha20), authentication, and integrity checks.

  • Use Cases: Secure server management, tunneling, automation.

FTP (File Transfer Protocol)

  • Purpose: Transfers files between systems over a network.

  • Ports: TCP/21 (control), TCP/20 (data).

  • Security: No encryption; credentials and files sent in plaintext.

  • Use Cases: Non-sensitive file sharing, legacy systems.

SFTP (SSH File Transfer Protocol)

  • Purpose: Secure file transfer over an encrypted SSH connection.

  • Port: TCP/22 (uses SSH).

  • Security: Inherits SSH's encryption and authentication.

  • Use Cases: Secure file transfers, compliance-driven environments.

Key Features Comparison

Feature

Telnet

SSH

FTP

SFTP

Encryption

None

AES, ChaCha20, etc.

None

AES, ChaCha20 (via SSH)

Authentication

Plaintext credentials

Public/private keys, passwords

Plaintext credentials

SSH keys, passwords

Data Integrity

No

Yes (HMAC)

No

Yes (via SSH)

Ports

23

22

20/21

22

Security Risks

High (sniffing, MITM attacks)

Low (if properly configured)

High (sniffing, data leaks)

Low (depends on SSH security)

Use Cases

Legacy device management (avoid in production)

Secure remote administration, scripting

Non-critical file transfers (internal use)

Secure file transfers, compliance (HIPAA, PCI-DSS)

Compliance

Non-compliant

Required for secure environments

Non-compliant

Required for secure environments

Summary of Use Cases

  • Telnet:

    • Avoid in production. Only for legacy/internal systems with no security requirements.

  • SSH:

    • Default for secure remote access, tunneling, and automation.

  • FTP:

    • Suitable for non-sensitive transfers where simplicity is prioritized (e.g., local networks).

  • SFTP:

    • Secure alternative to FTP; ideal for sensitive data, compliance, and encrypted transfers.


Key Takeaways:

  • Security: SSH/SFTP > FTP > Telnet.

  • Encryption: SSH and SFTP encrypt all traffic; Telnet/FTP expose data.

  • Compliance: SSH and SFTP meet modern standards; Telnet/FTP are obsolete for regulated use. Always prefer SSH/SFTP for secure operations. Use FTP only in isolated, non-sensitive environments.

Last updated